# Real Property I — Present Estates, Defeasible Fees, Future Interests, Rule Against Perpetuities & Concurrent Estates

> Exhaustive MBE black-letter law on fee simple absolute, defeasible fees, life estates, future interests (reversions, remainders, executory interests), the Rule Against Perpetuities, and concurrent estates.

- **Canonical URL:** https://flashcards.world/flashcards/sets/07e06ca3-77b4-4df5-afd8-861a55e68c2f/
- **Markdown URL:** https://flashcards.world/flashcards/sets/07e06ca3-77b4-4df5-afd8-861a55e68c2f.md
- **Level:** basic
- **Languages:** en → en
- **Total Cards:** 32

## Flashcards (32 Cards)

| # | Front (Term / Prompt) | Back (Definition / Answer) | Example | Multiple-Choice Options |
| :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- |
| 1 | What is the difference between a Vested Remainder and a Contingent Remainder? | • Vested Remainder: Created in an ascertained living person AND not subject to any condition precedent (other than natural expiration of prior estate). • Contingent Remainder: Created in an unascertained/unborn person (e.g., 'to the heirs of B' while B is alive) OR subject to an express condition precedent that must occur before the remainderperson has a right to possession (e.g., 'to B if B reaches age 30'). |  |  |
| 2 | What are the characteristics and creation language of a Fee Simple Absolute? | • Creation Language: Historically 'to A and his heirs'; modern law presumes fee simple from 'to A' without words of inheritance. • Characteristics: Absolute ownership of potentially infinite duration. It is freely alienable (transferable inter vivos), devisable (transferable by will), and descendible (passes by intestate succession). No future interest is retained by grantor or created in third parties. |  |  |
| 3 | What is the Rule Against Perpetuities (RAP), and what is its fundamental test? | Rule: No interest in property is good unless it must vest, if at all, not later than 21 years after some life in being at the creation of the interest. Test: You must determine whether there is ANY theoretical possibility, however remote, that the interest will vest or fail more than 21 years after the death of all measuring lives alive at the time the interest was created. If any such possibility exists, the interest is completely VOID at its inception. |  |  |
| 4 | What is a Fee Simple Subject to Executory Limitation (FSSEL), and how does it operate? | • Creation: Either durational ('so long as') or conditional ('provided that') language where, upon the occurrence of the stated condition or event, the estate automatically shifts to a THIRD PARTY rather than the grantor. • Example: 'To A, but if the land ceases to be used for park purposes, then to B and his heirs.' • Operation: Estate automatically divests from grantee and vests in the third party (who holds an Executory Interest). |  |  |
| 5 | What is the legal validity of Restraints on Alienation? | • Total Restraints on a Fee Simple: Total or absolute restraints on alienation of a fee simple estate (e.g., 'to A, but if A ever sells or transfers, to B') are VOID as contrary to public policy. The grantee takes a fee simple absolute unencumbered by the restraint. • Partial Restraints: Valid ONLY IF reasonable in purpose, scope, and duration (e.g., right of first refusal at fair market value for a reasonable limited time). |  |  |
| 6 | How is a Joint Tenancy severed, and what is the legal result? | • Severance Events:   1. Inter vivos conveyance of a joint tenant's interest to a third party (destroys unities of time and title);   2. Judicial partition (in kind or by sale);   3. Mutual agreement of joint tenants;   4. Execution of a mortgage in Title Theory states. • Legal Result: The conveyance severs the joint tenancy as to the transferred share, converting that grantee's interest into a Tenancy in Common with the remaining owners. |  |  |
| 7 | What are the three classifications of Vested Remainders? | 1. Indefeasibly Vested Remainder: Held by an ascertained person with certainty of obtaining possession; will never be defeated or diminished (e.g., 'to A for life, then to B'); 2. Vested Remainder Subject to Open (Partial Divestment): Vested in a class of persons that can grow larger by adding new members (e.g., 'to A for life, then to A's children', when A has at least one child); 3. Vested Remainder Subject to Complete Divestment: Vested in an ascertained person, but subject to a condition subsequent that could completely wipe out the interest before possession begins (e.g., 'to A for life, then to B, but if B fails the bar exam, then to C'). |  |  |
| 8 | Who qualifies as a 'Measuring Life' (Life in Being) under the Rule Against Perpetuities? | A Measuring Life must be: 1. A living human being (not an entity, corporation, or unborn person); 2. Alive at the exact moment the interest is created (at deed delivery for inter vivos conveyances; at testator's death for wills); 3. A person whose life or death is connected to or affects the vesting or termination of the interest in question. |  |  |
| 9 | How are the Grantor's Future Interests transferred at common law vs. modern property law? | • Reversion: Freely alienable inter vivos, devisable by will, and descendible by intestacy at both common law and modern law. • Possibility of Reverter & Right of Entry: At common law, these could not be transferred inter vivos (could only descend by intestacy). Modern majority rule: Both possibilities of reverter and rights of entry are fully transferable inter vivos, devisable by will, and descendible. |  |  |
| 10 | What are the characteristics, creation language, and future interest of a Fee Simple Determinable (FSD)? | • Creation Language: Durational language: 'so long as', 'while', 'during', 'until' (e.g., 'to A so long as the land is used for school purposes'). • Operation: Automatically terminates and reverts to grantor upon the occurrence of the stated event without any required action by grantor. • Future Interest: The grantor retains a Possibility of Reverter. |  |  |
| 11 | What are the financial and maintenance duties of a Life Tenant to the Remainderperson? | • Maintenance: Life tenant must keep property in reasonable state of repair to prevent permissive waste; • Carrying Costs: Life tenant must pay all ordinary property taxes and interest on existing mortgages (up to the extent of rental value or income derived from land); • Principal: Life tenant is NOT responsible for paying the principal amount of mortgage encumbrances (principal is paid by remainderperson); • Insurance: Life tenant has no duty to insure the property for remainderperson's benefit. |  |  |
| 12 | What is the difference between a Shifting Executory Interest and a Springing Executory Interest? | • Shifting Executory Interest: Divests or cuts short the interest of another transferee / third party (e.g., 'to A for life, then to B, but if B dies without issue, to C'—C's interest shifts from transferee B to C). • Springing Executory Interest: Divests or cuts short the grantor or grantor's estate following a gap in seisin (e.g., 'to A when A reaches age 21'—title springs out of grantor when A reaches 21). |  |  |
| 13 | What are the characteristics of a Tenancy in Common (TIC)? | • Presumption: Modern law presumes concurrent owners hold as tenants in common unless express survivorship language is used. • Characteristics:   1. Separate but undivided fractional interest in the whole property;   2. Unity of Possession is the only required unity;   3. NO right of survivorship;   4. Each tenant's interest is fully alienable inter vivos, devisable by will, and descendible by intestacy. |  |  |
| 14 | How does the Rule of Convenience apply to Class Gifts in property conveyances? | The Rule of Convenience closes a class gift whenever any class member is entitled to demand immediate possession of their share (usually upon the termination of the preceding life estate). • Consequence: Once the class closes, no future persons born after that date can join the class, ensuring prompt distribution. • Exception: If a child was conceived before the class closed and born alive afterwards, the child is included. |  |  |
| 15 | What are the rules regarding Possession and Ouster between Co-Tenants? | • Right to Possession: Each co-tenant has the legal right to possess and enjoy the entire property. A co-tenant in exclusive physical possession owes NO rent to out-of-possession co-tenants in the absence of an ouster. • Ouster: Occurs when a possessing co-tenant wrongfully excludes, evicts, or denies the right of entry to another co-tenant. Upon ouster, the possessing tenant must pay the ousted co-tenant their fractional share of the fair rental value of the property, and the statutory clock for Adverse Possession begins. |  |  |
| 16 | What are the three types of Waste that a Life Tenant is prohibited from committing? | 1. Affirmative (Voluntary) Waste: Deliberate or overt conduct causing a substantial decrease in property value or exploiting natural resources (Open Mines Doctrine exception: life tenant may continue mining open mines already exploited by grantor); 2. Permissive Waste (Inaction): Life tenant fails to preserve property, make ordinary repairs, pay property taxes, or pay interest on mortgages; 3. Ameliorative Waste: Unauthorized physical alterations that substantially change premises, even if increasing economic market value (excused if market value substantially impaired by changed surrounding conditions). |  |  |
| 17 | What are the three Future Interests retained by a Grantor? | 1. Reversion: Retained when grantor conveys a possessory estate of lesser duration than grantor's own estate (e.g., conveys life estate or leasehold) without disposing of the residual fee; 2. Possibility of Reverter: Retained automatically whenever grantor conveys a Fee Simple Determinable; 3. Right of Entry (Power of Termination): Retained explicitly whenever grantor conveys a Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent. |  |  |
| 18 | What are a Co-Tenant's rights to Contribution for Carrying Costs, Repairs, and Improvements? | • Carrying Costs (Taxes and Mortgage Interest): A co-tenant who pays more than their proportional share is entitled to mandatory contribution from other co-tenants (offset by rental value if paying tenant was in exclusive possession). • Necessary Repairs: A co-tenant who makes necessary repairs has NO affirmative right to compel contribution, but may seek an offset in an accounting action or partition. • Improvements: NO right to contribution for improvements; at partition, improver receives the added value created by improvement (or suffers the loss if value declined). |  |  |
| 19 | What is the difference between Partition in Kind and Partition by Sale? | • Partition in Kind: The court physically divides the tract of land into separate, distinct parcels proportional to each co-tenant's fractional ownership interest. This is the legally favored method of partition. • Partition by Sale: The court orders the real property sold at public auction and divides the net financial proceeds proportionally among co-tenants. Ordered ONLY when physical partition in kind is impossible, impracticable, or would substantially prejudice the interests of the owners. |  |  |
| 20 | What is a Remainder, and what distinguishes it from an Executory Interest? | A Remainder is a future interest created in an ascertained or unascertained transferee (third party) capable of becoming possessory immediately upon the natural termination of the preceding possessory freehold estate created in the same conveyance. Key Distinction: A remainder NEVER cuts short or divests a prior estate (it patiently waits for the prior estate to end naturally). An executory interest, by contrast, operates by cutting short, divesting, or springing up to interrupt a prior possessory estate or gap in seisin. |  |  |
| 21 | What is a Right of First Refusal (Preemptive Right), and how does it relate to the Rule Against Perpetuities? | A preemptive right granting the holder the option to purchase property on the same terms offered by a bona fide third-party purchaser before the property is sold to that third party. • Common Law Rule: Rights of first refusal in transferees are subject to the Rule Against Perpetuities; if the right could theoretically be exercised beyond 21 years after lives in being, it is void. • Modern Trend: Many states exempt commercial preemptive rights and rights of first refusal from RAP by statute. |  |  |
| 22 | How does a Mortgage affect the severance of a Joint Tenancy under Lien Theory vs. Title Theory? | • Lien Theory (Majority): A mortgage is treated merely as a security lien on property, not a transfer of legal title. Therefore, execution of a mortgage by one joint tenant does NOT sever the joint tenancy. If mortgagor dies first, the surviving joint tenant takes title free and clear of the mortgage. • Title Theory (Minority): A mortgage transfers legal title to the mortgagee. Therefore, execution of a mortgage by one joint tenant severs the unities and permanently converts the estate into a Tenancy in Common. |  |  |
| 23 | When must a Co-Tenant Account to other co-tenants for Rents and Profits? | • Third-Party Rents: A co-tenant who leases the property to a third party or collects rents/profits from third-party usage MUST account to all other co-tenants and distribute net rents based on their fractional ownership interests. • Personal Exploitation / Profits: A co-tenant who personally farms or operates an ordinary business on the land without third-party leases owes no share of net profits to co-tenants unless there is an ouster or depletion of natural resources (waste). |  |  |
| 24 | What are the 'Four Unities' required to create a Joint Tenancy with Right of Survivorship (JTRS)? | The Four Unities (TTIP): 1. Time: Interests must be acquired or vest at the same time; 2. Title: Interests must be created by the same instrument (deed or will); 3. Interest: All joint tenants must have equal, identical shares and estates of identical duration; 4. Possession: Each joint tenant must have an equal right to possess and enjoy the whole. Survivorship Language: Clear, explicit words of survivorship (e.g., 'as joint tenants with right of survivorship') are strictly required. |  |  |
| 25 | What are the classic Rule Against Perpetuities traps: The Fertile Octogenarian and The Unborn Widow? | • Fertile Octogenarian: Common law irrebuttably presumes that any living person, regardless of age or physical capacity (even an 80-year-old woman), is legally capable of having children. Thus, gifts to 'children' or 'grandchildren' can theoretically expand decades later. • Unborn Widow: A gift conditioned on surviving a life tenant's 'widow' violates RAP because the life tenant might marry someone not yet born at the time the instrument was drafted. |  |  |
| 26 | What modern statutory reforms have been adopted to modify or soften the common law Rule Against Perpetuities? | 1. 'Wait-and-See' Doctrine (Majority): Validity of the interest is determined not by what might happen at inception, but by waiting to see what actually happens during the perpetuities period; 2. Uniform Statutory Rule Against Perpetuities (USRAP): Adopts a flat 90-year alternate perpetuities period; 3. Cy Pres Doctrine: Authorizes courts to reform or rewrite the conveyance (e.g., reducing age contingencies from 25 to 21) to match grantor's intent while complying with RAP. |  |  |
| 27 | What are the characteristics, creation language, and future interest of a Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent (FSSCS)? | • Creation Language: Conditional language coupled with right of re-entry: 'upon condition that', 'provided that', 'but if' (e.g., 'to A, but if alcohol is sold on the premises, grantor reserves the right to re-enter'). • Operation: Does NOT terminate automatically. Grantor must take affirmative legal action (file ejectment action or physically re-enter) to cut short the estate. • Future Interest: The grantor retains a Right of Entry (or Power of Termination). |  |  |
| 28 | What is a Tenancy by the Entirety (TBE), and what unique protections does it provide? | • Marital Concurrent Estate: Available only to married couples; requires the 4 TTIP unities plus the Unity of Marriage (recognized in approximately half of states). • Right of Survivorship: Automatically passes to surviving spouse upon death of other spouse. • Protections: Neither spouse can unilaterally convey, encumber, partition, or transfer the property without the consent of the other; individual creditors of only one spouse cannot attach or execute upon TBE property. |  |  |
| 29 | What were the three historic common law property doctrines (Shelley's Case, Worthier Title, Destructibility) and their modern status? | • Rule in Shelley's Case: Conveyance 'to A for life, remainder to A's heirs' merged into a fee simple absolute in A. Modern status: ABOLISHED in virtually all states (heirs take contingent remainder). • Doctrine of Worthier Title: Conveyance by grantor 'to A for life, remainder to grantor's heirs' converted remainder to a reversion in grantor. Modern status: Largely abolished or treated only as rule of construction. • Destructibility of Contingent Remainders: Contingent remainder destroyed if it failed to vest prior to termination of preceding freehold. Modern status: ABOLISHED; becomes executory interest. |  |  |
| 30 | Which property interests are Subject to the Rule Against Perpetuities, and which are Exempt? | • Subject to RAP:   1. Contingent Remainders;   2. Executory Interests;   3. Vested Remainders Subject to Open (Class Gifts). • Exempt from RAP:   1. All future interests retained by the Grantor (Reversions, Possibilities of Reverter, Rights of Entry);   2. Indefeasibly Vested Remainders;   3. Vested Remainders Subject to Complete Divestment. |  |  |
| 31 | When does a Chattel become a Fixture, and what is the Trade Fixtures exception? | • Fixture: A personal chattel that becomes so affixed or annexed to real property that the law treats it as part of the realty. Determined by: (1) degree of physical annexation, (2) adaptation of chattel to use of realty, and (3) objective intent of the annexor. • Trade Fixtures Exception: Commercial tenants may remove equipment, machinery, and fixtures installed for trade or business before the expiration of the lease, provided removal does not cause substantial, permanent structural damage to the premises (tenant must repair any incidental damage). |  |  |
| 32 | What are the characteristics and creation language of a Life Estate? | • Creation Language: 'To A for life' (or 'to A for the life of B' for a Life Estate Pur Autre Vie). • Characteristics: An estate whose duration is measured solely by the lifetime of one or more specified living persons. The life tenant may transfer or lease their interest, but the interest terminates upon the measuring life's death. Always followed by a future interest: Reversion in grantor, or Remainder in third party. |  |  |

---
Study this deck interactively with FSRS-6 spaced repetition, audio review, and multiple-choice mode at [Flashcards World](https://flashcards.world/flashcards/sets/07e06ca3-77b4-4df5-afd8-861a55e68c2f/).