MEE Business Associations & Corporate Law — Agency, Partnerships, Fiduciary Duties, Business Judgment Rule & Derivative Suits
High-yield Multistate Essay Examination (MEE) corporate law: agency authority, general and limited partnerships, piercing corporate veil, fiduciary duties of care/loyalty, BJR, shareholder suits, and freeze-outs.
- Category
- MPRE Legal Ethics, Legal Latin, MEE Subjects (Corporations, Wills/Trusts, Family) & UK SQE
- Level
- intermediate
- Languages
- en → en
- Cards
- 32
- Markdown
- MEE Business Associations & Corporate Law — Agency, Partnerships, Fiduciary Duties, Business Judgment Rule & Derivative Suits (.md)
Flashcards (32)
| # | Front (Term / Question) | Back (Definition / Answer) | Example | Multiple-Choice Options |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | What are the three essential elements required to create an Agency Relationship under Restatement (Third) of Agency § 1.01? | 1. Manifestation of Consent: Consent by both principal and agent that agent will act; 2. On Principal's Behalf: Agent undertakes to act primarily for benefit of principal; 3. Under Principal's Control: Agent agrees to act subject to principal's direction and right of control. No consideration or formal writing is required (unless equal dignities rule applies for contracts within Statute of Frauds). | ||
| 2 | What is a Promoter's liability on Pre-incorporation Contracts, and how is the corporation bound? | • Promoter Liability: A promoter remains Personally Liable on contracts entered into on behalf of a corporation not yet formed, even after corporation is formed, UNLESS: (1) Contract explicitly states promoter is not liable, or (2) The third party, corporation, and promoter execute a Novation releasing promoter; • Corporate Liability: The corporation is NOT bound by pre-incorporation contracts unless it Adopts the contract after incorporation (expressly by board resolution, or impliedly by knowingly accepting benefits). | ||
| 3 | What are Shareholder Inspection Rights under DGCL § 220 and MBCA § 16.02? | A shareholder has the statutory right upon written demand under oath to inspect corporation's books and records (stock ledger, board minutes, financial records) for any 'Proper Purpose.' • Proper Purpose: A purpose reasonably related to such person's interest as a shareholder (e.g., investigating director mismanagement, valuing shares, communicating with other shareholders about proxy contests). Purely personal or fishing expeditions are improper purposes. | ||
| 4 | How must a Corporate Board of Directors act, and what are Quorum requirements? | Directors can act ONLY collectively: (1) At a duly convened regular or special meeting; OR (2) By Unanimous Written Consent signed by all directors without a meeting. Individual directors have no individual agency authority to bind corporation. • Quorum: A majority of the authorized number of directors must be present to transact business (unless charter/bylaws specify higher/lower, min 1/3). Passing a resolution requires majority vote of directors PRESENT. | ||
| 5 | What creates a General Partnership under the Revised Uniform Partnership Act (RUPA § 202)? | The association of two or more persons to carry on as co-owners a business for profit forms a partnership, whether or not the persons intended to form a partnership. No formal writing or state filing required. • Statutory Presumption: A person who receives a share of profits of a business is presumed to be a partner, unless profits received in payment of a debt, wages, rent, interest, or sale of goodwill. | ||
| 6 | What is Director Oversight Liability under the Caremark and Marchand doctrines? | Under In re Caremark and Marchand v. Barnhill, directors breach their duty of loyalty / good faith by failing in oversight ONLY IF: (1) Directors utterly failed to implement any reporting or information system or controls; OR (2) Having implemented systems, consciously failed to monitor or oversee operations, disabling themselves from being informed of risks/problems ('red flags'). Requires bad faith / sustained conscious neglect of duty. | ||
| 7 | What is the difference between Partner Dissociation and Partnership Dissolution under RUPA Articles 6 and 8? | • Dissociation (Article 6): Change in relationship caused by a partner ceasing to be associated in carrying on business (withdrawal, expulsion, bankruptcy, death). Does not automatically terminate partnership; partnership may buy out dissociated partner's interest and continue; • Dissolution (Article 8): Event triggering Winding Up of partnership business (liquidation of assets, payment of creditors, distribution of surplus to partners). Occurs in at-will partnership upon notice of partner's express will to withdraw, or upon stated event or judicial decree. | ||
| 8 | What are the grounds for 'Piercing the Corporate Veil' to hold shareholders personally liable? | Courts disregard corporate separateness and hold shareholders personally liable when: (1) Alter Ego / Mere Conduit: Unity of interest and ownership where corporate formalities are ignored (commingling personal and corporate funds, failure to hold meetings/keep records); (2) Undercapitalization: Corporation intentionally capitalized with insufficient funds to meet reasonably foreseeable debts/liabilities; and (3) Fraud or Injustice: Maintaining corporate shield would sanction fraud or promote injustice. Rarely applied in contract; more common in tort. | ||
| 9 | What are the requirements for a Principal to Ratify an unauthorized transaction entered into by an agent? | Ratification validates unauthorized act as if authorized from beginning. Requires: (1) Agent purported to act on behalf of principal; (2) Principal has full knowledge of all material facts of transaction; (3) Principal manifests assent or accepts benefits of transaction; (4) Timely: Must occur before third party withdraws; and (5) Principal must ratify entire transaction (cannot cherry-pick benefits while disclaiming burdens). | ||
| 10 | What fiduciary duties do Controlling Shareholders owe, and what is the MFW Framework for freeze-out mergers? | Controlling shareholders owe fiduciary duties not to use control to extract private benefits at expense of minority shareholders (e.g., selling control to a known looter, unfair self-dealing). • Kahn v. M&F Worldwide (MFW): A controlling shareholder freeze-out merger receives deferential Business Judgment Rule review (rather than onerous Entire Fairness review) ONLY IF conditioned ab initio upon BOTH: (1) Negotiation and approval by an independent, fully empowered Special Committee of directors; AND (2) Uncoerced, fully informed vote of a Majority of the Minority shareholders. | ||
| 11 | What is the Corporate Opportunity Doctrine (Guth v. Loft line-of-business test)? | A director or officer cannot usurp for personal gain a business opportunity belonging to corporation without first presenting it to board and receiving refusal. Opportunity belongs to corporation if: (1) Corporation is financially able to undertake it; (2) Opportunity is in corporation's Line of Business; (3) Corporation has practical interest or reasonable expectancy; and (4) Personal exploitation will create conflict with corporate duties. | ||
| 12 | How do courts determine whether property belongs to the Partnership or to an Individual Partner (RUPA § 204)? | • Partnership Property: Presumed to be partnership property if acquired in name of partnership, or in name of one or more partners with indication of partner capacity or reference to partnership, OR acquired with partnership funds; • Individual Partner Property: Acquired in individual partner's name without partnership funds and without indication of partner capacity, even if used for partnership purposes. Partners have no transferable interest in specific partnership property (only their partnership interest/profits). | ||
| 13 | What are the rules governing Shareholder Voting Proxies? | A shareholder may vote in person or by written proxy executed by shareholder (valid for 11 months under default rules). • General Rule: Proxies are freely revocable at will by shareholder (by delivering written revocation, executing subsequent proxy, or voting in person at meeting); • Irrevocable Proxy: A proxy is irrevocable ONLY IF: (1) It explicitly states it is irrevocable, AND (2) It is 'Coupled with an Interest' (e.g., proxy given to pledgee, purchaser of shares, creditor, or party to voting agreement). | ||
| 14 | What is the liability of General Partners for partnership obligations under RUPA § 306? | All general partners are Jointly and Severally liable for all debts, contract obligations, and tort liabilities of the partnership. An incoming partner is liable for pre-existing debts only to extent of capital contribution. Outgoing dissociated partner remains liable for debts incurred while a partner. • Exhaustion Requirement: Creditor must obtain judgment against partnership and exhaust partnership assets before levying against individual partners' personal assets. | ||
| 15 | How do courts distinguish between a Direct Shareholder Lawsuit and a Derivative Lawsuit (The Tooley Test)? | Under the Delaware Tooley test, courts analyze two questions to classify the claim: 1. Who suffered the alleged harm: The corporation as an entity, or the suing shareholder individually? 2. Who would receive the benefit of any recovery or other remedy: The corporation, or the shareholders individually? • Direct Suit: Injury is to shareholder directly (e.g., denied right to vote, dividend declared but unpaid, preemptive rights violated); • Derivative Suit: Harm is to corporation (e.g., director breach of duty of care/loyalty, waste, usurping corporate opportunity). Recovery goes entirely to corporation. | ||
| 16 | What is the contractual liability of Principal and Agent when Principal is Disclosed, Partially Disclosed, or Undisclosed? | • Disclosed Principal (third party knows principal's existence and identity): Principal liable; agent NOT liable unless expressly agreed; • Partially Disclosed / Unidentified Principal (third party knows principal exists, but not identity): Both Principal and Agent are liable (third party may sue either); • Undisclosed Principal (third party unaware principal exists): Both Principal and Agent are liable; third party may hold agent personally liable, and once discovered, can hold principal liable. | ||
| 17 | What procedural steps are required for Fundamental Corporate Changes (Mergers, Asset Sales, Charter Amendments)? | Fundamental corporate changes require a four-step process: 1. Board of Directors adopts a resolution proposing the fundamental change; 2. Board submits proposal to shareholders with written notice of shareholder meeting; 3. Shareholder Approval: Approved by a majority of shares entitled to vote (or majority of votes cast under modern MBCA); 4. Filing: Formal articles of merger, dissolution, or amendment filed with Secretary of State. (Exception: Short-form merger of 90%+ subsidiary requires no subsidiary shareholder vote). | ||
| 18 | What is the Delaware Unified Test for Demand Futility in Derivative Litigation (United Food v. Zuckerberg)? | Delaware eliminated the separate Aronson and Rales tests, establishing a unified 3-part demand futility inquiry evaluated on a director-by-director basis for at least half the board: 1. Did director receive a material personal benefit from alleged transaction? 2. Does director face a substantial likelihood of personal liability on claim? or 3. Does director lack independence from someone who received a material benefit or faces a substantial likelihood of liability? If majority meets any prong, demand is futile and excused. | ||
| 19 | What are the Safe Harbors for Interested Director Transactions under DGCL § 144 and MBCA § 8.61? | A contract between corporation and a director (or director's business) is not voidable solely due to conflict if any of three safe harbors is met: 1. Approval by Fully Informed Disinterested Directors: Material facts disclosed and transaction approved by majority of disinterested directors; 2. Approval by Fully Informed Shareholders: Material facts disclosed and approved by majority of disinterested voting shareholders; OR 3. Fairness: Transaction was Fair and Reasonable to corporation at the time entered into (Entire Fairness Standard: fair dealing and fair price). | ||
| 20 | What are the rules governing Corporate Distributions and Dividends under MBCA § 6.40? | Dividends are declared at discretion of Board of Directors; shareholders have no automatic right to compel dividends absent bad faith or abuse of discretion. • Statutory Insolvency Test: Board CANNOT declare distribution if, after giving it effect: (1) Equity Insolvency: Corporation unable to pay debts as they become due in usual course of business; OR (2) Balance Sheet Insolvency: Total assets would be less than total liabilities plus preferential dissolution rights of senior preferred shares. Directors voting for unlawful distribution are personally liable. | ||
| 21 | What is the Business Judgment Rule (BJR) and how can it be rebutted? | A rebuttable judicial presumption that in making a business decision, directors acted on an informed basis, in good faith, and in honest belief that action was in best interests of corporation. Courts will not second-guess business decisions or hold directors liable for mere errors of judgment. Rebutted by showing director: (1) Acted in bad faith; (2) Was interested/self-dealing; (3) Committed gross negligence (uninformed decision); (4) Committed illegal acts; or (5) Committed corporate waste. | ||
| 22 | When is a Principal vicariously liable for torts of an Agent under Respondeat Superior? | Principal is vicariously liable for torts committed by an agent if: (1) Master-Servant / Employer-Employee relationship exists (principal exercises control over physical details and manner of work); and (2) Tort committed within Scope of Employment (performing duties hired to do or actuated by intent to serve principal). Principals generally not liable for Independent Contractors unless non-delegable duty or ultra-hazardous activity. | ||
| 23 | What are the elements of Apparent Authority and how can a principal terminate it? | Apparent authority exists when: (1) Principal holds out or manifests to a Third Party that agent has authority to act; and (2) Third party Reasonably Relies on that manifestation to their detriment (cannot be created solely by agent's own representations). Termination: Principal must provide actual notice to third parties who previously dealt with agent, and constructive notice (publication) to other third parties. | ||
| 24 | What are the doctrines of De Facto Corporation and Corporation by Estoppel? | Equitable defenses when incorporation papers are defectively filed: • De Facto Corporation: Shareholders enjoy limited liability if: (1) Relevant incorporation statute exists; (2) Good-faith, colorable attempt to comply; and (3) Exercise of corporate privileges; • Corporation by Estoppel: A third party who dealt with entity treating it as a corporation is estopped from denying corporate existence to hold shareholders personally liable (applies in contract claims, not torts). | ||
| 25 | What is the Director Fiduciary Duty of Care under MBCA § 8.30 and Smith v. Van Gorkom? | A director must discharge duties: (1) In good faith; (2) With the care that an ordinarily prudent person in a like position would reasonably exercise under similar circumstances; and (3) In a manner reasonably believed to be in best interests of corporation. • Duty to be Informed (Smith v. Van Gorkom): Directors must inform themselves of all material information reasonably available before making decisions (gross negligence standard for breach; entitled to rely on officers, financial experts, and legal counsel). | ||
| 26 | What Fiduciary Duties do partners owe to the partnership and each other under RUPA § 404? | • Duty of Loyalty (RUPA § 404(b)): Limited to: (1) Accounting for any property, profit, or benefit derived from partnership business/property; (2) Refraining from dealing with partnership as or on behalf of an adverse party; and (3) Refraining from competing with partnership; • Duty of Care (RUPA § 404(c)): Refraining from engaging in grossly negligent or reckless conduct, intentional misconduct, or knowing violation of law; • Obligation of Good Faith and Fair Dealing (RUPA § 404(d)). | ||
| 27 | What is the difference between Actual Express Authority and Actual Implied Authority? | • Actual Express Authority: Explicit oral or written instructions directly communicated by principal to agent granting power to act. • Actual Implied Authority: Authority agent reasonably believes they possess based on principal's conduct, communications, or circumstances, including: (1) Incidental authority (acts necessary to carry out express authority); (2) Customary authority (acts customary in business/industry); (3) Prior acquiescence by principal. | ||
| 28 | What is an Exculpatory Charter Provision under DGCL § 102(b)(7) and what are its limits? | Corporate charter may eliminate or limit personal liability of directors (and now officers under 2022 amendments) to corporation or shareholders for monetary damages for breach of Fiduciary Duty of Care. STRICT LIMITATIONS: Cannot eliminate or limit liability for: (1) Breach of Duty of Loyalty; (2) Acts or omissions not in good faith or involving intentional misconduct or knowing violation of law; (3) Unlawful dividend distributions or stock repurchases (§ 174); or (4) Improper personal benefit. | ||
| 29 | What are Dissenting Shareholder Appraisal Rights and when are they available? | Statutory right of a shareholder dissenting from a fundamental change (e.g., merger, sale of substantially all assets) to obtain judicial appraisal of the 'Fair Value' of their shares paid in cash. • Prerequisites: Shareholder must: (1) Deliver written notice of intent to demand payment before shareholder vote; (2) Not vote in favor of transaction; and (3) Make timely written demand for payment after approval; • Market-Out Exception: Appraisal rights unavailable if shares are publicly traded on national exchange or held by 2,000+ shareholders. | ||
| 30 | What are the procedural prerequisites to filing a Derivative Lawsuit? | 1. Standing (Contemporaneous & Continuous Ownership): Plaintiff must have been a shareholder at the time of the alleged wrongdoing AND must continuously remain a shareholder throughout litigation; 2. Fair and Adequate Representation: Plaintiff must fairly and adequately represent interests of corporation and similarly situated shareholders; 3. Demand Requirement: Plaintiff must make written Demand on Board of Directors to bring suit and wait 90 days (MBCA universal demand), UNLESS demand is excused as Futile. | ||
| 31 | What are the structural distinctions between a General Partnership, a Limited Partnership (LP), and an LLC? | • General Partnership: All partners manage and have unlimited personal liability; no state filing; • Limited Partnership (LP): Must file with state; has at least one General Partner (unlimited personal liability, manages business) and at least one Limited Partner (limited liability up to investment, traditionally passive investors under ULPA); • Limited Liability Company (LLC): Must file Articles of Organization; all members enjoy limited liability for debts; can be Member-Managed or Manager-Managed. | ||
| 32 | How do courts evaluate a Special Litigation Committee's (SLC) motion to dismiss a derivative suit (The Zapata Two-Step)? | Under Zapata Corp. v. Maldonado, when an independent board committee moves to dismiss a derivative suit as not in corporation's best interest, court applies two-step review: • Step 1: Court inquires into independence and good faith of committee members and the bases supporting their conclusions (burden on committee; if not independent, motion denied); • Step 2: Court applies its OWN Independent Business Judgment to determine whether motion should be granted, balancing corporate commercial interests with legal public policy. |