Criminal Law & Procedure — Actus Reus, Mens Rea, Common Law & MPC Homicide, Felony Murder, Inchoate Crimes & 4th/5th/6th Amendments

Detailed mastery of actus reus, mens rea, homicide, felony murder, inchoate crimes, defenses, Fourth Amendment search and seizure, Miranda interrogations, and Sixth Amendment counsel.

Category
1L & 2L Law Deep Dive: Real Property I & II, Criminal Law/Pro, Constitutional Law I & II & Evidence
Level
basic
Languages
en → en
Cards
32
Markdown
Criminal Law & Procedure — Actus Reus, Mens Rea, Common Law & MPC Homicide, Felony Murder, Inchoate Crimes & 4th/5th/6th Amendments (.md)

Flashcards (32)

#Front (Term / Question)Back (Definition / Answer)ExampleMultiple-Choice Options
1Does mere presence create Accomplice Liability, and how does an accomplice effectively Withdraw?• Mere Presence: Mere presence at the crime scene, even with knowledge of criminal activity or failure to intervene, does NOT constitute accomplice liability. • Withdrawal Requirements: 1. If accomplice merely encouraged: Must repudiate encouragement and communicate withdrawal to principal before crime occurs; 2. If accomplice provided material assistance: Must neutralize assistance (e.g., retrieving weapon, alerting police) in time to prevent crime.
2Under what narrow circumstances is Mistake of Law a valid defense in Criminal Law?General Rule: Ignorance of the law or mistake of law is NO defense ('ignorantia juris non excusat'). Exceptions: 1. Statute explicitly includes knowledge of law as an element of offense; 2. Reasonable reliance on an official interpretation of law later determined invalid (statute, judicial opinion of highest court, or official administrative opinion); 3. Criminal statute was not published or reasonably made available prior to conduct (Lambert v. California).
3What triggers the requirement for Miranda Warnings, and what defines Custody and Interrogation?Miranda warnings are required prior to Custodial Interrogation by law enforcement: • Custody: A formal arrest or a restraint on freedom of movement to the degree associated with a formal arrest (judged by objective reasonable person standard; routine traffic stop is not custody: Berkemer v. McCarty). • Interrogation (Rhode Island v. Innis): Express questioning or any words or actions by police that police know or should know are reasonably likely to elicit an incriminating response.
4How does Mistake of Fact operate as a defense across Specific Intent, General Intent, and Strict Liability crimes?• Specific Intent Crimes: ANY honest, good-faith mistake of fact negates specific intent, even if the mistake was unreasonable or foolish. • General Intent Crimes: Only a REASONABLE mistake of fact negates general criminal intent; an unreasonable mistake is no defense. • Strict Liability Crimes: Mistake of fact is NEVER a defense, because strict liability crimes require no proof of mental culpability.
5How do Voluntary Intoxication and Involuntary Intoxication operate as criminal defenses?• Voluntary Intoxication: Self-induced intoxication is a defense ONLY to specific intent crimes if it prevented the formation of the required specific intent. It is NEVER a defense to general intent, malice (e.g., depraved heart murder), or strict liability crimes. • Involuntary Intoxication: Intoxication resulting from duress, fraud, or medical mistake without knowledge of intoxicating character. Treated as temporary insanity, providing a complete defense to ALL crimes.
6What are the major tests for the Insanity Defense (M'Naghten, Irresistible Impulse, MPC)?• M'Naghten Rule (Majority): Due to mental disease/defect, defendant either: (1) did not know the nature and quality of the act, OR (2) did not know that the act was wrong; • Irresistible Impulse: Mental disease made defendant unable to control impulses or conform conduct to law; • MPC / ALI Test: Defendant lacked substantial capacity either to appreciate the criminality of conduct or conform conduct to requirements of law.
7When does an Omission to act constitute criminal Actus Reus?There is no general common law duty to rescue or prevent crime. An omission creates criminal liability ONLY IF defendant had a specific legal duty to act and was physically capable of performing it: 1. Statutory Duty (tax returns, child neglect reporting); 2. Status Relationship (parent-child, spouse-spouse); 3. Contractual Obligation (lifeguard, nurse, railroad crossing guard); 4. Voluntary Assumption of Care (beginning care and isolating victim from other aid); 5. Creation of Peril (defendant caused the dangerous condition).
8How do First-Degree Murder and Second-Degree Murder differ under modern statutory frameworks?• First-Degree Murder (Statutory): (1) Premeditated and deliberate intentional killings (premeditation requires reflecting upon intent to kill beforehand, even briefly), or (2) Enumerated Felony Murder (killing during burglary, arson, robbery, rape, kidnapping). • Second-Degree Murder: All other common law murders with malice aforethought (intent to inflict grievous bodily injury, depraved-heart extreme recklessness, and un-enumerated felony murder).
9What are the elements of Accomplice Liability, and what is the scope of responsibility?• Elements: (1) Intent to assist, encourage, or facilitate the principal in the commission of the crime, AND (2) Intent that the principal commit the substantive crime. • Scope: Accomplice is liable for the intended target crime AND all other reasonably foreseeable crimes committed by the principal that are the natural and probable consequences of the original target crime. • Punishment: An accomplice is punished to the exact same extent as the principal perpetrator.
10What are the four Model Penal Code (MPC) Mens Rea levels under MPC § 2.02?1. Purposely: Conscious object to engage in conduct of that nature or cause such result; 2. Knowingly: Practically certain that conduct will cause result, or aware that circumstances exist; 3. Recklessly (Default MPC state): Consciously disregards a substantial and unjustifiable risk involving gross deviation from standard of conduct; 4. Negligently: Should be aware of a substantial and unjustifiable risk; failure to perceive is gross deviation from reasonable care.
11What constitutes Malice Aforethought in Common Law Murder?Common Law Murder is the unlawful killing of a human being with malice aforethought, proven by any of four distinct mental states: 1. Intent to Kill (express malice; includes deadly weapon doctrine); 2. Intent to Inflict Grievous Bodily Harm; 3. Depraved-Heart Murder: Extreme reckless indifference to an unjustifiably high risk to human life; 4. Felony Murder: Killing proximately caused during commission or attempted commission of an inherently dangerous felony.
12What is the Exclusionary Rule and the Fruit of the Poisonous Tree doctrine, with its four exceptions?• Exclusionary Rule: Evidence obtained in violation of Fourth, Fifth, or Sixth Amendment is inadmissible at trial. Fruit of Poisonous Tree excludes derivative evidence tainted by initial illegal search. • Exceptions permitting admission: 1. Independent Source (evidence obtained through independent untainted source); 2. Inevitable Discovery (evidence would inevitably have been discovered by lawful means); 3. Attenuation of Taint (passage of time, intervening circumstances); 4. Good-Faith Exception (United States v. Leon: reasonable reliance on defective warrant).
13What is the Automobile Exception to the Fourth Amendment, and how does it compare to SILA in vehicles under Arizona v. Gant?• Automobile Exception (Carroll doctrine): If police have Probable Cause to believe a vehicle contains contraband or evidence of crime, they may search the entire vehicle, including trunk and any locked containers that could contain the object of the search, without a warrant. • Search Incident to Arrest in Vehicles (Arizona v. Gant): Police may search the passenger compartment only if: (1) arrestee is unsecured and within reaching distance of vehicle at time of search, or (2) reasonable to believe vehicle contains evidence of the offense of arrest.
14What is the Felony Murder Rule, and what felonies qualify under the BARRK mnemonic?A killing committed during the commission or attempted commission of an inherently dangerous felony is murder, without requiring proof of intent to kill. • Inherently Dangerous Felonies (BARRK): Burglary, Arson, Robbery, Rape, Kidnapping. • Limitations: 1. Independent Felony (Merger) Doctrine: The underlying felony must be independent of the killing (e.g., aggravated assault merges into homicide and cannot serve as predicate); 2. Killing must occur during immediate flight/escape.
15How does the Agency Theory of Felony Murder differ from the Proximate Cause Theory?• Agency Theory (Majority): The felony murder rule applies ONLY if the fatal act was committed by the felon or a co-felon. If a police officer, bystander, or victim fires a fatal shot killing an innocent person or a co-felon, the surviving felons cannot be convicted of felony murder. • Proximate Cause Theory (Minority): Felons are liable for ANY death that is proximately caused by the felonious operation, even if the fatal shot was fired by police or a resisting victim.
16What are the two forms of Involuntary Manslaughter?1. Criminal Negligence Manslaughter: An unintentional killing resulting from gross negligence (conduct involving a high degree of risk of death or serious bodily injury, substantially deviating from reasonable care, but lacking extreme depraved-heart malice); 2. Unlawful Act (Misdemeanor) Manslaughter: An accidental killing committed during the commission of an unlawful misdemeanor or non-BARRK felony.
17What are the elements of Solicitation, and what is its Merger doctrine?• Elements: Asking, inciting, commanding, or encouraging another person to commit a felony with the specific intent that the person commit the crime. The crime is complete upon asking, whether or not the other person agrees. • Merger: Solicitation MERGES into the target completed crime if committed, and merges into Conspiracy if the solicited party agrees. Defendant cannot be convicted of both solicitation and the completed crime or conspiracy.
18When does the Sixth Amendment Right to Counsel attach, and what makes it 'Offense-Specific'?• Attachment: Attaches automatically upon the initiation of formal adversary judicial criminal proceedings (formal charge, indictment, information, or preliminary hearing/arraignment). • Offense-Specific (Texas v. Cobb): The Sixth Amendment right applies ONLY to the specific criminal offenses charged and closely related offenses under Blockburger. Police may question defendant about uncharged, unrelated crimes without counsel present (unlike Fifth Amendment Edwards rule).
19What are the recognized Specific Intent Crimes at Common Law?Specific Intent Crimes (SCAFFEL-RBF): • Solicitation • Conspiracy • Attempt • First-Degree Premeditated Murder • Assault (attempted battery type) • Larceny • Embezzlement • False Pretenses • Robbery • Burglary • Forgery Significance: Unreasonable mistake of fact and voluntary intoxication are valid defenses ONLY to specific intent crimes.
20What are the elements of Conspiracy at Common Law vs. under modern statutes / MPC?• Common Law: (1) An agreement between two or more persons (bilateral agreement), (2) with the specific intent to enter into the agreement, and (3) specific intent to achieve the unlawful objective. No overt act was required. • Modern Rule / MPC: Requires an OVERT ACT in furtherance of conspiracy (mere preparation suffices); under MPC § 5.04, Unilateral conspiracy is recognized (person can be guilty even if agreeing with an undercover police officer). • NO Merger: Conspiracy never merges into the completed target crime.
21What is the Voluntary Act requirement for Actus Reus in Criminal Law?A person cannot be guilty of a crime unless liability is based on conduct that includes a voluntary bodily movement. • Involuntary Acts: Reflexes, convulsions, unconscious acts, acts performed during epileptic seizures or sleepwalking, or bodily movements coerced by physical force do not satisfy actus reus. • Possession: Conscious possession satisfies actus reus if defendant knowingly procured or received the item, or was aware of control for sufficient time to terminate possession.
22What are the elements of Criminal Attempt, and what are the tests for the overt act?• Elements: (1) Specific intent to commit the target crime, AND (2) an overt act in furtherance of that intent beyond mere preparation. • Overt Act Tests: 1. Common Law Proximity Test: Act must be dangerously close to physical completion; 2. MPC Substantial Step Test: Conduct that constitutes a 'substantial step' in the course of conduct planned to culminate in the crime, strongly corroborative of criminal purpose. • Merger: Attempt merges into the completed crime.
23When is Deadly Force justified in Self-Defense, and what are the rules regarding Initial Aggressors?• Deadly Force Standard: Permitted only when defender reasonably believes that the other person is about to inflict imminent death or serious bodily injury. • Initial Aggressor Rule: An initial aggressor cannot claim self-defense UNLESS: 1. The aggressor effectively withdraws from conflict and clearly communicates that withdrawal to the other party; OR 2. The other party suddenly escalates a non-deadly conflict into a deadly encounter without giving aggressor opportunity to retreat.
24What are the four requirements for Voluntary Manslaughter (Heat of Passion)?Reduces intentional murder to voluntary manslaughter if: 1. Adequate Provocation: Provocation that would arouse sudden and intense passion in an ordinary reasonable person, causing them to lose self-control (mere insulting words alone are insufficient); 2. Actual Passion: Defendant was in fact impassioned; 3. No Reasonable Cooling-Off Period: Insufficient time between provocation and fatal act for a reasonable person to cool off; and 4. No Actual Cooling Off: Defendant did not in fact cool off.
25What is the scope of the Fifth Amendment Privilege Against Self-Incrimination?Protects individuals from being compelled in any civil, criminal, or administrative proceeding to give Testimonial evidence that could be used in a criminal prosecution. • Testimonial: Communication or assertion of facts from defendant's mind. • Non-Testimonial Evidence: The Fifth Amendment does NOT protect against physical or biometric evidence (fingerprints, DNA, blood samples, voice exemplars, handwriting samples, or lineup appearances). • Immunity: Use and derivative-use immunity eliminates privilege and compels testimony.
26What is the Pinkerton Doctrine in Conspiracy Law?Pinkerton v. United States (1946): Each member of a conspiracy is criminally liable for all substantive offenses committed by any co-conspirator if those offenses were: 1. Committed in furtherance of the conspiracy's unlawful objective; and 2. A natural and reasonably foreseeable consequence of the conspiracy. Co-conspirator need not participate in, know of, or agree to the specific substantive crime.
27What are the two prongs of the Strickland v. Washington test for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel?To establish ineffective assistance of counsel under Sixth Amendment, defendant must prove: 1. Deficient Performance: Counsel's representation fell below an objective standard of reasonableness under prevailing professional norms (strong presumption that conduct was sound trial strategy); 2. Prejudice: A reasonable probability that, but for counsel's unprofessional errors, the result of the proceeding would have been different (probability sufficient to undermine confidence in outcome).
28What are the four common law Mens Rea mental states?1. Specific Intent: Subjective intent to engage in prohibited conduct AND achieve a specific unlawful result; 2. General Intent: Intent to perform the physical act prohibited by law, regardless of whether actor intended specific harm (recklessness or negligence often suffices); 3. Malice: Reckless disregard of a known, obvious, and substantial risk of harm (applies strictly to common law Murder and Arson); 4. Strict Liability: No mental state required; performing physical act creates guilt.
29What are the constitutional requirements for a Terry Stop vs. a Terry Frisk?• Terry Stop: An investigatory detention justified by Reasonable Articulable Suspicion based on specific, articulable facts that criminal activity is afoot (more than a hunch, less than probable cause). Duration must be brief and diligent. • Terry Frisk: A protective pat-down of outer clothing permitted ONLY IF the officer has reasonable suspicion that the detainee is armed and dangerous. Limited to feeling for weapons (Plain Feel doctrine: contraband detected without manipulation is admissible).
30What is the Katz Reasonable Expectation of Privacy test for Fourth Amendment searches?Under Katz v. United States (1967) (Harlan concurrence), a government inspection constitutes a Fourth Amendment 'search' if: 1. The individual has exhibited an actual, subjective expectation of privacy; AND 2. The expectation is one that society is prepared to recognize as objectively reasonable. • Jones Trespass Test (United States v. Jones, 2012): A physical intrusion or trespass onto a constitutionally protected area (person, house, papers, effects) to gather information is also a search.
31What are the eight recognized Warrant Exceptions to the Fourth Amendment (ESCAPIST)?1. Exigent Circumstances (hot pursuit, evanescent evidence, emergency aid); 2. Search Incident to Lawful Arrest (SILA); 3. Consent (voluntary, given by person with actual or apparent authority); 4. Automobile Exception (probable cause of evidence allows search of entire vehicle and containers); 5. Plain View (lawfully present, item in plain sight, incriminating character immediately apparent); 6. Inventory Search (standardized administrative procedures upon impoundment); 7. Special Needs (border searches, school searches, airport checkpoints); 8. Terry Stop and Frisk.
32What are the rules regarding the Invocation and Waiver of Miranda Rights under Edwards v. Arizona?• Invocation of Right to Silence: Must be explicit and unambiguous (Berghuis v. Thompkins). Police must 'scrupulously honor' invocation by halting questioning, but may re-approach after significant time on different crime. • Invocation of Right to Counsel (Edwards Rule): Must be unambiguous request for attorney. ALL questioning MUST immediately cease until attorney is present, UNLESS suspect re-initiates communication voluntarily (expires after 14-day break in custody: Maryland v. Shatzer).