Contracts II — Statute of Frauds, Parol Evidence Rule, Conditions, Anticipatory Repudiation, Breach & Remedies
In-depth treatment of the Statute of Frauds, Parol Evidence Rule, express and constructive conditions, anticipatory repudiation, adequate assurances, impracticability, and remedies.
- Category
- 1L Law School Deep Dive: Torts I & II, Contracts I & II (UCC Art. 2) & Civil Procedure I & II
- Level
- intermediate
- Languages
- en → en
- Cards
- 32
- Markdown
- Contracts II — Statute of Frauds, Parol Evidence Rule, Conditions, Anticipatory Repudiation, Breach & Remedies (.md)
Flashcards (32)
| # | Front (Term / Question) | Back (Definition / Answer) | Example | Multiple-Choice Options |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | What are the four statutory exceptions to the UCC Statute of Frauds (SWAP)? | 1. Specially Manufactured Goods: Goods made specially for buyer, unsuitable for sale to others in ordinary business, and seller made substantial beginning of manufacture; 2. Written Confirmation between Merchants: Sender sends written confirmation within reasonable time, recipient knows contents and fails to object in writing within 10 days of receipt; 3. Admission in Court: Party against whom enforcement is sought admits in pleading, testimony, or deposition that contract was made (enforceable to quantity admitted); 4. Performance: Payment made and accepted, or goods received and accepted. | ||
| 2 | How does a Demand for Adequate Assurances operate under UCC § 2-609 and Restatement § 251? | When reasonable grounds for insecurity arise regarding a party's performance: • The insecure party may demand in writing adequate assurance of due performance; • May suspend own performance until receiving assurance; • The other party must provide adequate assurance within a reasonable time, not exceeding 30 DAYS under UCC § 2-609; • Failure to provide adequate assurance within 30 days operates as an Anticipatory Repudiation. | ||
| 3 | How do Express Conditions differ from Constructive Conditions, and what standard of compliance applies to each? | • Express Condition: Explicitly agreed by parties ('conditioned upon', 'provided that', 'if and only if'). Requires STRICT and literal compliance. Failure of an express condition excuses the other party's duty of performance without breach. • Constructive (Implied) Condition: Created by law to establish the order of performances (e.g., performing services precedes payment). Governed by the SUBSTANTIAL PERFORMANCE doctrine rather than strict compliance. | ||
| 4 | What is the Perfect Tender Rule under UCC § 2-601, and what are its exceptions? | Under UCC § 2-601, if goods or the tender of delivery fail in any respect to conform to the contract, the buyer may: (1) reject the whole, (2) accept the whole, or (3) accept any commercial unit(s) and reject the rest. Exceptions: 1. Seller's Right to Cure (§ 2-508); 2. Installment Contracts (§ 2-612): Buyer can reject an installment only if non-conformity substantially impairs the value of that installment and cannot be cured; 3. Contractual limitation of remedies. | ||
| 5 | What are the elements of Frustration of Purpose established in Krell v. Henry? | Discharges performance where: 1. A supervening event occurs; 2. The non-occurrence of which was a basic assumption of the contract; 3. The event virtually destroys the entire mutually understood purpose or value of the contract for the party seeking excuse; and 4. Neither party was at fault, and risk was not allocated to the affected party. Krell v. Henry (1903): Flat rented specifically to view the King's coronation parade; coronation postponed due to King's illness, completely frustrating the sole purpose of the lease. | ||
| 6 | Under what circumstances does a Seller have a Right to Cure under UCC § 2-508? | 1. Time for Performance Has Not Yet Expired (§ 2-508(1)): Seller has an absolute right to cure if seller seasonably notifies buyer of intention to cure and makes a conforming tender within the contractual delivery timeframe. 2. Time for Performance Has Expired (§ 2-508(2)): Seller has a further reasonable time to substitute a conforming tender IF seller had reasonable grounds to believe the tender would be acceptable with or without a money allowance (e.g., prior course of dealing). | ||
| 7 | What are the elements of the defense of Commercial Impracticability under UCC § 2-615 and Restatement § 261? | 1. Occurrence of a supervening event; 2. The non-occurrence of which was a basic assumption on which the contract was made; 3. Event made performance extremely and unreasonably burdensome, expensive, or difficult; 4. Party seeking excuse did not assume the risk; and 5. Event occurred without the fault of the party seeking discharge. Note: Normal price fluctuations or market shifts are inherent business risks and do NOT constitute impracticability. | ||
| 8 | What is the Certainty Requirement for recovering damages in contract breach? | Damages must be proven with reasonable certainty; speculative or conjectural damages are strictly unrecoverable. • Lost Profits: Traditional 'new business rule' barred new businesses from recovering lost profits due to lack of track record. Modern trend permits new businesses to recover lost profits if proven with reasonable certainty through expert financial modeling, comparable business profits, and market analysis. | ||
| 9 | What are the two requirements for a valid Liquidated Damages clause, and what makes a clause an unenforceable Penalty? | Under common law and UCC § 2-718(1), a liquidated damages clause is enforceable ONLY IF: 1. At the time of contract formation, anticipated damages in the event of breach were uncertain or difficult to ascertain; and 2. The amount stipulated is a reasonable forecast of just compensation for the anticipated or actual harm. Unenforceable Penalty: If the fixed sum is designed to compel performance through threat of punitive forfeiture, or provides an arbitrary lump sum regardless of the severity of the breach, it is void as a penalty. | ||
| 10 | How are a Seller's Damages measured under UCC § 2-706 (Resale), § 2-708(1) (Market), and § 2-708(2) (Lost Volume Seller)? | • Resale (§ 2-706): Contract Price minus Resale Price, plus incidental damages, minus expenses saved (resale must be commercially reasonable with notice to buyer). • Market Damages (§ 2-708(1)): Contract Price minus Market Price at time and place of tender, plus incidental damages, minus expenses saved. • Lost Volume Seller (§ 2-708(2)): If seller has unlimited supply and could have made two sales instead of one, resale does not make seller whole. Seller recovers the Lost Profit (including reasonable overhead) that would have been earned from full performance by buyer. | ||
| 11 | What was established in Jacob & Youngs v. Kent regarding Substantial Performance and Material Breach? | Jacob & Youngs v. Kent (1921): Builder installed Cohoes pipe instead of specified Reading pipe; quality and value were identical. Cardozo held builder substantially performed in good faith, and the breach was minor/trivial. Rule: Substantial performance satisfies constructive conditions of exchange. The non-breaching party must perform their reciprocal duty (pay the contract price), but may deduct or recover damages measured by the diminution in value rather than cost of replacement if replacement would involve unreasonable economic waste. | ||
| 12 | What is the Duty to Mitigate Damages, and what was held in Rockingham County v. Luten Bridge Co.? | A non-breaching party cannot recover for avoidable losses that could have been prevented by reasonable efforts without undue risk, burden, or humiliation. • Rockingham County v. Luten Bridge Co. (1929): County repudiated contract to build bridge and ordered builder to stop. Builder continued building anyway and sued for full contract price. Court held builder had duty to stop work and mitigate damages; could recover only accrued costs plus lost profits up to the repudiation date. | ||
| 13 | What are the six contractual categories covered by the Statute of Frauds (MYLEGS)? | 1. Marriage: Contracts made upon consideration of marriage (prenuptial/postnuptial agreements); 2. Year: Contracts that cannot possibly be performed within One Year from the date of contract formation; 3. Land: Contracts for the sale, mortgage, or transfer of an interest in real property (including leases exceeding 1 year); 4. Executor: Contracts where an executor/administrator promises to pay estate debts from their own personal funds; 5. Goods: Contracts for the sale of goods priced at $500 or more (UCC § 2-201); 6. Suretyship: Contracts promising to answer for the debt or default of another person. | ||
| 14 | What are the requirements for Specific Performance, and why is it unavailable for Personal Services contracts? | Requirements: 1. Valid, enforceable contract with definite and certain terms; 2. Inadequacy of legal remedies (money damages insufficient, e.g., real estate or rare/unique goods under UCC § 2-716); 3. Feasibility of court enforcement and supervision; 4. Mutuality of performance. Personal Services Prohibition: Courts will NEVER order specific performance of personal service contracts because it violates the 13th Amendment prohibition against involuntary servitude and requires difficult judicial supervision. | ||
| 15 | How are a Buyer's Damages measured under UCC § 2-712 (Cover) vs. § 2-713 (Market Damages)? | • Cover Damages (§ 2-712): When seller breaches, buyer may in good faith and without unreasonable delay purchase substitute goods. Damages = Cover Price minus Contract Price, plus incidental and consequential damages, minus expenses saved. • Market Damages (§ 2-713): If buyer does not cover. Damages = Market Price at the time buyer learned of breach minus Contract Price, plus incidental and consequential damages, minus expenses saved. | ||
| 16 | What constitutes the Part Performance Exception to the Statute of Frauds in Land Sale Contracts? | In a contract for the transfer of an interest in land, oral agreements become enforceable under equity if the buyer establishes at least two of the following three acts of part performance: 1. Payment of all or part of the purchase price; 2. Taking possession of the real property; 3. Making substantial, valuable permanent improvements to the property. | ||
| 17 | What is an Anticipatory Repudiation, and what options does the non-repudiating party possess? | An unequivocal, unambiguous statement or affirmative conduct by a party before time of performance arrives indicating they cannot or will not perform their contractual obligations. Options of Non-Repudiating Party: 1. Treat the repudiation as an immediate total breach and sue for damages; 2. Suspend own performance and wait to see if repudiating party performs by the due date; 3. Treat the contract as canceled/rescinded; 4. Urge the repudiator to retract and perform. | ||
| 18 | How is the One-Year Provision of the Statute of Frauds calculated, and what does the 'possibility of performance' rule dictate? | • Time Calculation: The one-year period is measured from the exact date the contract is formed until the completion of performance (not from the start of performance). • Possibility of Performance: The contract is within the Statute of Frauds ONLY IF full performance within one year is theoretically impossible under the terms. If there is any theoretical possibility, however remote, of full performance within one year (e.g., contract for lifetime employment, because person could die within a year), it is NOT within the SOF and needs no writing. | ||
| 19 | When are Reliance Damages awarded in lieu of Expectation Damages? | Reliance damages put the injured party in the position they would have occupied had the contract never been entered into. • Used when expectation damages are too speculative, uncertain, or impossible to calculate (e.g., profits of a novel, untried venture, as in Security Stove v. American Ry. Express); • Covers out-of-pocket expenses incurred in preparation for or in performance of the contract; • Limitation: Reliance damages cannot exceed the full expectation damages (contract price) that would have been earned. | ||
| 20 | How do Intended Beneficiaries differ from Incidental Beneficiaries, and when do an intended beneficiary's rights Vest? | • Intended Beneficiary: Explicitly intended by promisee to benefit (creditor or donee beneficiary); has legal standing to enforce the contract directly against promisor. • Incidental Beneficiary: Benefits incidentally without intent of contracting parties; has NO enforceable rights. • Vesting of Rights: Rights vest when beneficiary: (1) assents to promise in manner invited, (2) materially changes position in justifiable reliance, or (3) brings suit to enforce promise. Once vested, original parties cannot modify or rescind without beneficiary's consent. | ||
| 21 | What are the requirements for the defense of Objective Impossibility? | Performance is discharged where an unanticipated supervening event makes performance objectively impossible ('it cannot be done by anyone', not merely 'I cannot do it'). Classic categories: 1. Death or physical incapacity of a person necessary for personal performance; 2. Destruction of the specific subject matter or essential thing necessary for performance (e.g., music hall burns down in Taylor v. Caldwell); 3. Supervening illegality making performance outlawed. | ||
| 22 | What are the rules governing Assignment of Rights and Delegation of Duties? | • Assignment of Rights: All contractual rights are assignable UNLESS assignment materially changes obligor's duty, increases risk/burden, or is barred by statute/contract. Anti-assignment clause: 'assignment void' invalidates; 'assignment prohibited' creates breach damages but transfer is effective. • Delegation of Duties: All duties are delegable UNLESS they involve personal skill, judgment, artistic talent, or special trust/confidence. The delegating obligor remains secondary liable to obligee unless a novation occurs. | ||
| 23 | Under what circumstances may an Anticipatory Repudiation be Retracted? | The repudiating party can retract the repudiation at any time before performance is due UNLESS the non-repudiating party has: 1. Canceled or terminated the contract; 2. Materially and detrimentally changed their position in reliance on the repudiation; or 3. Communicated to the repudiating party that they consider the repudiation final and binding. | ||
| 24 | What are the writing requirements for the Sale of Goods ($500+) under UCC § 2-201? | A contract for goods priced at $500 or more is unenforceable unless there is a writing that: 1. Evidences a contract for the sale of goods; 2. Is signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought (or their authorized agent); and 3. Specifies a QUANTITY term. Notice: The price, delivery date, and payment terms need NOT be stated, but the contract is enforceable only up to the quantity of goods stated in the writing. | ||
| 25 | What is a Novation, and how does it differ from a simple delegation of contractual duties? | A Novation is a separate tripartite agreement where all three parties (obligee, original obligor, and substituted new obligor) agree to completely discharge the original obligor and substitute the new obligor in their place. Difference from Delegation: In a simple delegation, the original delegating obligor remains continuously liable as a surety if the delegatee fails to perform. In a novation, the original obligor is completely and permanently released from all contractual liability. | ||
| 26 | What are the recognized exceptions where the Parol Evidence Rule does NOT bar extrinsic evidence? | 1. Formation Defects: Fraud, duress, mistake, illegality, or lack of consideration; 2. Conditions Precedent: Oral agreement that the contract would not become effective until a condition occurred; 3. Ambiguity / Interpretation: Extrinsic evidence to explain ambiguous terms; 4. Course of Performance, Course of Dealing, and Trade Usage (UCC § 1-303 / § 2-202); 5. Subsequent Modifications: PER only applies to prior or contemporaneous agreements; agreements entered into AFTER the execution of the writing are never barred by PER. | ||
| 27 | What factors determine whether a contractual breach is Material vs. Minor under Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 241? | 1. Extent to which injured party will be deprived of the benefit reasonably expected; 2. Extent to which injured party can be adequately compensated for the deprived benefit; 3. Extent to which breaching party will suffer forfeiture; 4. Likelihood that breaching party will cure failure, taking into account all circumstances; 5. Extent to which behavior of breaching party conforms to standards of good faith and fair dealing. | ||
| 28 | What is Restitution (Quantum Meruit), and when is it available in contract disputes? | Restitution prevents unjust enrichment by restoring to the plaintiff the reasonable value of any benefit conferred upon the defendant. • Available to a non-breaching party upon total breach as an alternative to expectation damages (measured by market value of benefit conferred, even if it exceeds contract price); • Available to a breaching party who conferred valuable net benefits before breaching (quantum meruit minus damages caused by breach); • Available when contract is unenforceable due to Statute of Frauds, incapacity, or mistake. | ||
| 29 | What is the formula for Expectation Damages, and what is its fundamental purpose? | Purpose: Put the non-breaching party in the economic position they would have occupied had the contract been fully performed according to its terms. Formula: Loss in Value (what was promised minus what was received) + Other Losses (incidental and consequential damages) - Cost Avoided (expenses saved by not having to complete performance) - Loss Avoided (salvage value or mitigated losses by reallocating resources). | ||
| 30 | What is the Parol Evidence Rule (PER), and how does it distinguish between Total Integration and Partial Integration? | PER bars extrinsic evidence of prior oral/written agreements or contemporaneous oral agreements that contradict a written contract intended as the final expression of the parties. • Completely Integrated Agreement: Intended as a complete and exclusive statement of terms. Extrinsic evidence cannot be introduced to contradict OR supplement the writing with consistent additional terms. • Partially Integrated Agreement: Final expression of terms included, but not exhaustive. Extrinsic evidence is admissible to supplement with consistent additional terms, but cannot contradict. | ||
| 31 | What is the rule of Foreseeability for Consequential Damages established in Hadley v. Baxendale? | Consequential (special) damages are recoverable only if they were reasonably foreseeable to the breaching party at the time of contract formation. Two categories: 1. Naturally Arising: Arising naturally from the breach according to the usual course of things; or 2. Special Circumstances: In the contemplation of both parties at formation as the probable result of breach because special circumstances were explicitly communicated to the defendant (Hadley v. Baxendale: miller failed to inform carrier that mill was stopped for lack of shaft; lost profits were unrecoverable). | ||
| 32 | What are the methods by which a condition may be Excused? | 1. Wrongful Prevention / Bad Faith: The party benefited by the condition hinders, prevents, or fails to cooperate in its occurrence; 2. Waiver: The party benefited by the condition knowingly and voluntarily relinquishes the condition; 3. Estoppel: Party indicates they will not insist on condition, and other party detrimentally relies; 4. Impossibility / Extreme Forfeiture: Occurrence of condition becomes impossible and excusing it does not materially alter the bargain. |