Federal Rules of Evidence (FRE) — Relevance (401/403), Character & MIMIC (404), Impeachment (608/609), Privileges & Hearsay Exceptions (801–804)

Mastery of the Federal Rules of Evidence including relevance, character evidence, MIMIC, witness impeachment, common law privileges, non-hearsay exemptions, and hearsay exceptions.

Category
1L & 2L Law Deep Dive: Real Property I & II, Criminal Law/Pro, Constitutional Law I & II & Evidence
Level
advanced
Languages
en → en
Cards
32
Markdown
Federal Rules of Evidence (FRE) — Relevance (401/403), Character & MIMIC (404), Impeachment (608/609), Privileges & Hearsay Exceptions (801–804) (.md)

Flashcards (32)

#Front (Term / Question)Back (Definition / Answer)ExampleMultiple-Choice Options
1What are the three primary Non-Hearsay uses of out-of-court statements?Statements not offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted: 1. Verbal Acts / Legally Operative Facts: Utterances that carry independent legal significance under substantive law (words of offer and acceptance, defamatory words, gift words, words of cancellation); 2. Effect on the Listener / Reader: Offered to show notice, knowledge, good faith, or motive of person who heard statement (e.g., warning: 'the stairs are icy'); 3. Circumstantial Evidence of Declarant's State of Mind: Demonstrating sanity/insanity or knowledge circumstantially ('I am Napoleon').
2What are the distinctions between Spousal Testimonial Privilege and Marital Communications Privilege?• Spousal Testimonial Privilege: Criminal cases only. Protects spouse from being compelled to testify against defendant-spouse. Witness-spouse holds privilege. Applies to events before and during marriage; terminates upon divorce. • Confidential Marital Communications: Civil and criminal cases. Protects confidential communications made between spouses DURING the valid marriage. BOTH spouses hold privilege (either spouse can prevent disclosure). Survives divorce, death, and dissolution of marriage.
3What is the general rule on Character Evidence in Civil Cases under FRE 404(a), and what are the exceptions?• General Rule: Evidence of a person's character or character trait is INADMISSIBLE to prove that on a particular occasion the person acted in accordance with that character (propensity). • Exceptions: Admissible only where character is an essential element of a claim or defense (ROCS: Reputation, Opinion, and Conduct/Specific acts allowed under FRE 405(b)): 1. Defamation (plaintiff's reputation); 2. Negligent Hiring / Retention / Entrustment; 3. Child Custody disputes.
4What are the elements of Attorney-Client Privilege, and what is the Crime-Fraud Exception?• Elements: (1) Confidential communication, (2) between client (or client's representative) and lawyer (or lawyer's representative), (3) made for the primary purpose of facilitating legal advice or services. Client holds privilege; lasts indefinitely (even after death). • Crime-Fraud Exception: The privilege does NOT apply if the legal advice or representation was sought or utilized to enable or aid anyone in committing or planning what client knew or should have known was a crime or fraud.
5What does the Rape Shield Law (FRE 412) prohibit, and what are its criminal exceptions?FRE 412: In any civil or criminal proceeding involving alleged sexual misconduct, evidence of the victim's sexual behavior or sexual predisposition is barred. Criminal Exceptions (Specific instances allowed): 1. To prove that someone other than the defendant was the source of semen, injury, or other physical evidence; 2. Specific instances of sexual behavior with the defendant to prove Consent; and 3. Exclusion would violate defendant's constitutional rights (Olden v. Kentucky).
6Who may Impeach a witness under FRE 607, and how may Character for Truthfulness be proved under FRE 608(a)?• FRE 607: Any party, including the party that called the witness, may attack the witness's credibility (impeach). • FRE 608(a): A witness's credibility may be attacked or supported by evidence in the form of Reputation or Opinion concerning their character for Truthfulness or Untruthfulness. Evidence of truthful character is admissible ONLY AFTER the witness's character for truthfulness has been attacked.
7What is the Test for Relevant Evidence under FRE 401 & 402?FRE 401: Evidence is relevant if: (a) It has any tendency to make a fact more or less probable than it would be without the evidence (Probative); and (b) The fact is of consequence in determining the action (Material). FRE 402: All relevant evidence is admissible unless excluded by the U.S. Constitution, federal statute, the FRE, or Supreme Court rules. Irrelevant evidence is inadmissible.
8What is the Balancing Test under FRE 403 for excluding relevant evidence?FRE 403: The court may exclude relevant evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by a danger of one or more of the following: • Unfair prejudice (appealing to jury's emotions or bias); • Confusing the issues; • Misleading the jury; • Undue delay; • Wasting time; or • Needlessly presenting cumulative evidence.
9What is the difference between Refreshing Recollection (FRE 612) and Prior Inconsistent Statements (FRE 613)?• Refreshing Recollection (FRE 612): Any writing or item may be shown to a witness to jog their memory. The writing is NOT admitted into evidence by the proponent; the witness testifies from refreshed memory. Opponent may inspect, cross-examine, and introduce relevant parts. • Prior Inconsistent Statement (FRE 613): Used to impeach credibility by showing witness made a contradictory statement earlier. Extrinsic evidence of statement is admissible only if witness is given an opportunity to explain or deny, and opponent can examine witness.
10What are the three categories of Prior Statements by Testifying Witnesses that are Excluded from Hearsay under FRE 801(d)(1)?If declarant testifies and is subject to cross-examination about prior statement: 1. 801(d)(1)(A): Prior Inconsistent Statement made under penalty of perjury at trial, hearing, deposition, or other proceeding (admissible as substantive evidence); 2. 801(d)(1)(B): Prior Consistent Statement offered to rebut an express/implied charge of recent fabrication or improper influence/motive (made before motive to fabricate arose); 3. 801(d)(1)(C): Prior Statement of Identification of a person made after perceiving the person.
11How do inquiries into Specific Instances of Conduct for Truthfulness operate under FRE 608(b)?On cross-examination, an attorney may inquire into specific instances of conduct of the witness IF they are probative of the witness's character for truthfulness or untruthfulness (e.g., lying on a job application, embezzlement, fraud, using a fake ID). • Ban on Extrinsic Evidence: The examiner MUST take the witness's answer. If the witness denies the act, the examiner CANNOT introduce extrinsic documents or call other witnesses to prove the act occurred.
12What are the non-propensity purposes for Other Crimes, Wrongs, or Acts under FRE 404(b) (MIMIC)?Inadmissible for propensity, but admissible to prove non-character purposes (MIMIC): • Motive • Intent • Mistake (Absence of mistake or accident) • Identity (signature / modus operandi) • Common Plan or Scheme Standard (Huddleston v. US): Prosecution must provide reasonable pretrial notice, and judge must determine that a reasonable jury could find the act occurred by a preponderance of the evidence.
13What distinguishes Lay Opinion Testimony (FRE 701) from Expert Testimony (FRE 702)?• Lay Opinion (FRE 701): Admissible if: (a) rationally based on witness's perception, (b) helpful to clear understanding of testimony or fact in issue, and (c) NOT based on scientific, technical, or specialized knowledge (e.g., speed of car, intoxication, emotional state, voice ID). • Expert Testimony (FRE 702 / Daubert): Qualified by knowledge, skill, experience, training, or education. Requires: (a) helpfulness, (b) sufficient facts/data, (c) reliable principles and methods, (d) reliably applied to facts of case.
14How do Then-Existing Mental/Physical Condition (FRE 803(3)) and Medical Diagnosis (FRE 803(4)) operate?• FRE 803(3): Statement of declarant's then-existing state of mind (motive, intent, plan) or emotional, sensory, or physical condition (pain, bodily health). Mutual Life Ins. v. Hillmon: Statements of intent can prove future conduct of declarant. Does not cover statements of memory or belief to prove the fact remembered. • FRE 803(4): Statements made for medical diagnosis or treatment describing medical history, symptoms, sensations, or inception/general cause, insofar as reasonably pertinent to diagnosis/treatment (statements attributing fault/blame are NOT pertinent).
15What Methods of Proving Character are permitted on Direct vs. Cross-Examination under FRE 405?• Direct Examination: When character evidence is admissible, it may be proved ONLY by testimony about the person's Reputation or Opinion (FRE 405(a)); specific instances of conduct are strictly prohibited on direct. • Cross-Examination: The court may allow inquiry into relevant Specific Instances of Conduct to test witness's knowledge and basis. Extrinsic evidence is prohibited; examiner must take witness's answer.
16What is the Sixth Amendment Confrontation Clause rule under Crawford v. Washington?Crawford v. Washington (2004): Out-of-court Testimonial statements by declarants who do not testify at trial are barred under the Sixth Amendment Confrontation Clause, UNLESS: 1. The declarant is unavailable; AND 2. The criminal defendant had a prior opportunity to cross-examine the declarant. • Testimonial: Statements made where primary purpose is to establish or prove past events potentially relevant to later criminal prosecution (Davis v. Washington: statements to 911 during ongoing emergency are non-testimonial; statements to police after emergency ends are testimonial).
17How do Offers to Pay Medical Expenses (FRE 409) differ from Plea Discussions (FRE 410)?• FRE 409: Evidence of furnishing or offering to pay medical, hospital, or similar expenses is inadmissible to prove liability. CRITICAL DISTINCTION: Accompanying statements of fact or admissions of fault ('I'll pay your bills, I ran the red light') are NOT protected and are admissible. • FRE 410: Withdrawn guilty pleas, nolo contendere pleas, and statements made during plea discussions with a prosecutor are inadmissible for any purpose in civil or criminal cases.
18How are Privileges governed in federal court under FRE 501?• Federal Question Cases: Governed by the principles of the Common Law as interpreted by federal courts in the light of reason and experience (Attorney-Client, Spousal, Psychotherapist-Patient; NO federal doctor-patient privilege). • Diversity Cases (Erie Doctrine): In civil actions regarding claims or defenses governed by state substantive law, State Privilege Law applies.
19What is the difference between a Present Sense Impression (FRE 803(1)) and an Excited Utterance (FRE 803(2))?• Present Sense Impression (FRE 803(1)): A statement describing or explaining an event or condition, made while or immediately after the declarant perceived it (virtually contemporaneous). • Excited Utterance (FRE 803(2)): A statement relating to a startling event or condition, made while the declarant was under the stress of excitement that it caused. The statement can be made after a time lapse, provided the declarant is still under the influence of the excitement.
20What is the scope of FRE 408 regarding Compromise Offers and Negotiations?• Inadmissible: Offers to settle, settlement acceptances, and statements/conduct made during compromise negotiations are barred to prove or disprove the validity or amount of a disputed claim, or to impeach by prior inconsistent statement. • Prerequisite: There must be an actual DISPUTE as to either liability/validity or the amount of the claim at the time negotiations occur. • Admissible: Permitted to prove witness bias/prejudice, negating a contention of undue delay, or obstruction of criminal investigation.
21What are the five grounds for Declarant Unavailability under FRE 804(a) (PRMDA)?A declarant is considered unavailable as a witness if the declarant: 1. Privilege: Exempt from testifying due to ruling that privilege applies; 2. Refusal: Refuses to testify despite court order; 3. Memory: Testifies to lack of memory of subject matter; 4. Death or physical/mental illness; 5. Absence: Absent and proponent cannot procure attendance by process or reasonable means. Proponent must not have wrongfully procured declarant's unavailability.
22What are the Former Testimony, Dying Declaration, and Statement Against Interest exceptions under FRE 804(b)?Requires Declarant Unavailability: • Former Testimony (804(b)(1)): Given under oath at hearing/deposition; party against whom offered (or predecessor in interest in civil case) had opportunity and similar motive to develop testimony. • Dying Declaration (804(b)(2)): Made while believing death was imminent, concerning cause or circumstances of impending death. Permitted ONLY in Homicide prosecutions and Civil actions (declarant need not die, but must be unavailable). • Statement Against Interest (804(b)(3)): At time made, so contrary to declarant's proprietary, pecuniary, or penal interest that reasonable person wouldn't say it unless true. In criminal cases, penal interest requires corroboration.
23How does the 'Mercy Rule' operate for a Criminal Defendant's Character under FRE 404(a)(2)(A)?• Opening the Door: A criminal defendant may initiate character evidence by introducing pertinent good character traits (e.g., peacefulness in homicide/battery; honesty in fraud/theft) via Reputation or Opinion testimony only. • Prosecution Rebuttal: Once defendant opens door, prosecution may: 1. Cross-examine defendant's character witness about specific instances of conduct ('Have you heard?' / 'Did you know?'); and 2. Call its own character witnesses to testify to defendant's bad reputation or contrary opinion.
24When may a Criminal Defendant introduce evidence of the Victim's Character under FRE 404(a)(2)(B)?Defendant may introduce pertinent character evidence of the victim (e.g., victim's violent character in a claim of self-defense) by reputation or opinion. Prosecution Rebuttal Options: 1. Introduce rebuttal evidence of victim's good trait for that same character; OR 2. Introduce evidence of defendant's own bad trait for that same character; and 3. In homicide cases: If defendant claims victim was first aggressor, prosecution may introduce victim's peaceful character without defendant opening door.
25What are the requirements for Witness Competency (FRE 601) and Personal Knowledge (FRE 602)?• FRE 601: Every person is presumed competent to be a witness unless the rules provide otherwise (in civil diversity cases, state competency law applies under Erie). • FRE 602: A witness may testify to a matter only if evidence is introduced sufficient to support a finding that the witness has Personal Knowledge of the matter (perceived through the witness's own senses). Expert witnesses under FRE 703 are exempt from personal knowledge requirement.
26When are Subsequent Remedial Measures inadmissible and admissible under FRE 407?• Inadmissible: Measures taken after an injury that would have made the harm less likely to occur cannot be admitted to prove negligence, culpable conduct, a defect in product or design, or a need for a warning. • Admissible: Permitted for non-culpability purposes IF DISPUTED: 1. Proving ownership or control; 2. Proving feasibility of precautionary measures; or 3. Impeachment.
27What are the rules for Impeachment by Criminal Conviction under FRE 609?1. Crimes of Dishonesty / False Statement (Crimen Falsi): MUST be admitted against any witness, whether felony or misdemeanor, without court discretion (FRE 609(a)(2)); 2. Felonies Not Involving Dishonesty (FRE 609(a)(1)): • Non-defendant witness: Admissible subject to standard FRE 403 balancing; • Criminal defendant witness: Admissible ONLY if probative value outweighs prejudicial effect (reverse-403); 3. Ten-Year Rule: If more than 10 years have passed since conviction or release (whichever later), conviction inadmissible unless probative value substantially outweighs prejudice with written notice.
28What is the definition of Hearsay under FRE 801(a)-(c)?Hearsay is a statement that: 1. The declarant does not make while testifying at the current trial or hearing; and 2. A party offers in evidence to PROVE THE TRUTH OF THE MATTER ASSERTED in the statement. • Statement: An oral assertion, written assertion, or nonverbal conduct if intended as an assertion. • If offered for any purpose other than proving the truth of the assertion, it is NOT hearsay.
29When is evidence of Liability Insurance inadmissible vs. admissible under FRE 411?• Inadmissible: Evidence that a person was or was not insured against liability is barred to prove whether the person acted negligently or otherwise wrongfully. • Admissible: Permitted for other purposes, such as proving agency, ownership, control, or witness bias or prejudice (e.g., showing insurance investigator is biased toward defendant).
30What five types of Opposing Party Statements are non-hearsay under FRE 801(d)(2)?Statement offered against an opposing party and was: 1. 801(d)(2)(A): Party's own individual statement; 2. 801(d)(2)(B): Adoptive admission (party manifested adoption or belief in truth, including silence where reasonable person would object); 3. 801(d)(2)(C): Statement made by person authorized to make statement on subject; 4. 801(d)(2)(D): Statement by party's agent or employee on matter within scope of that relationship, while relationship existed; 5. 801(d)(2)(E): Co-conspirator statement made during and in furtherance of conspiracy.
31What are the requirements for Business Records (FRE 803(6)) vs. Public Records (FRE 803(8))?• Business Records (803(6)): (1) Record made at or near time by person with knowledge, (2) kept in course of regularly conducted business activity, (3) regular practice to make record, and (4) certified by custodian or witness. • Public Records (803(8)): Records of a public office setting out: (a) office's activities, (b) matter observed while under legal duty to report (EXCLUDING police observations in criminal cases), or (c) factual findings from authorized civil/against-government investigation.
32What constitutes Habit or Routine Practice under FRE 406, and how does it differ from Character?FRE 406: Evidence of a person's Habit or an organization's Routine Practice is admissible to prove that on a particular occasion the person or organization acted in accordance with the habit or routine practice. • Distinction: Character is a generalized disposition (e.g., 'careful driver' or 'honest'); Habit is a semi-automatic, specific, highly repeated, regular response to a specific repeated situation (e.g., 'always stops at Railroad Crossing X and shifts to neutral').