Advanced Critical Reasoning Assumption/Strengthen/Weaken Traps
Necessary vs sufficient assumptions, negation test mechanics, strengthening with alternate cause elimination, subtle weakening traps, and boldface role analysis.
- Category
- GMAT
- Level
- advanced
- Languages
- en → en
- Cards
- 32
- Markdown
- Advanced Critical Reasoning Assumption/Strengthen/Weaken Traps (.md)
Flashcards (32)
| # | Front (Term / Question) | Back (Definition / Answer) | Example | Multiple-Choice Options |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Why are extreme words like 'primarily', 'only', and 'most important' usually red flags in Necessary Assumption choices? | Necessary assumptions represent the MINIMUM required conditions. Unless the author's conclusion explicitly claimed exclusivity or primacy, asserting that a factor is the 'primary' driver is too strong to be necessary. | ||
| 2 | What linguistic tone characterizes correct Sufficient Assumption choices? | Strong, categorical, and absolute language ('all', 'every', 'whenever', 'no exception'). Broad claims are effective because they guarantee the bridge from premise to conclusion. | ||
| 3 | What is the Statistical Baseline fallacy in GMAT CR arguments? | Comparing percentage gains across entities with radically different initial baselines (e.g., a 100% gain from a baseline of 1 is only +1, whereas a 5% gain from 1,000 is +50). | ||
| 4 | Can the Negation Test be used on Sufficient Assumption or Strengthen questions? | NO! The Negation Test is valid ONLY for Necessary Assumption questions. Applying it to Sufficient Assumption or Strengthen questions produces false negatives. | ||
| 5 | What is a 'Pseudo-Strengthener' trap in Necessary Assumption questions? | An answer choice that makes the conclusion sound more impressive or plausible in the real world, but whose negation does not destroy the author's specific baseline logic. | ||
| 6 | What linguistic tone characterizes correct Necessary Assumption choices? | Cautious, moderate, and minimal language ('at least some', 'not impossible', 'does not entirely depend on'). Moderate statements are much harder to refute upon negation. | ||
| 7 | What is the 'Cost vs. Profit' trap in business recommendation arguments? | Recommending an action purely because it reduces costs, while ignoring that the action may degrade product quality, driving away customers and destroying overall profitability. | ||
| 8 | What is the 'Feedback Loop / Equilibrium' trap in policy arguments? | Assuming external variables stay constant after an intervention, ignoring that the policy itself alters human incentives and creates offsetting behavioral adaptations. | ||
| 9 | What is the 'Temporal Lag' trap in causal arguments? | Concluding an intervention was ineffective because no results appeared immediately, ignoring that causal biological, economic, or behavioral mechanisms require multi-month incubation. | ||
| 10 | How do 'EXCEPT' questions work in Strengthen and Weaken CR? | • Which weakens EXCEPT: 4 choices weaken the argument; 1 choice either strengthens or has completely neutral impact. • Which strengthens EXCEPT: 4 choices strengthen; 1 choice either weakens or is neutral. | ||
| 11 | What is the 'Pre-existing Difference' flaw in controlled experiment arguments? | Concluding that treatment X caused the difference in outcome between Group A and Group B, ignoring that Group A differed fundamentally from Group B before the study began. | ||
| 12 | What is the 'Scope Match' rule in CR answer elimination? | The degree of certainty in the answer choice must align with the conclusion. If the conclusion is qualified ('may occasionally happen'), an answer proving it 'never happens' may be an irrelevant overreach. | ||
| 13 | What is the Technological Viability vs Commercial Adoption trap? | Assuming that because a new technology is scientifically proven to work, customers will adopt it and the company will achieve commercial profitability. | ||
| 14 | Why is eliminating an alternative explanation considered a powerful strengthener? | Because an argument is vulnerable to every competing cause. Knocking out an obvious rival hypothesis leaves the author's proposed cause as the surviving explanation. | ||
| 15 | What is the strict definition of a Sufficient Assumption in GMAT CR? | A premise that, if added to the argument, 100% guarantees the truth of the conclusion. It creates an airtight deductive proof, often providing more information than strictly necessary. | ||
| 16 | How does the Variance Test work in 'Evaluate the Argument' questions? | Test extreme polar answers to the question (e.g., 'Yes' vs 'No', or '100%' vs '0%'). One extreme must significantly strengthen the conclusion, and the other extreme must significantly weaken it. | ||
| 17 | How do you distinguish a 'Main Conclusion' from an 'Intermediate Conclusion'? | Apply the 'Therefore' test: 'Premise, therefore Intermediate Conclusion; therefore Main Conclusion.' The intermediate conclusion supports the main conclusion; the main conclusion supports nothing. | ||
| 18 | What is the strict definition of a Necessary Assumption in GMAT CR? | An unstated premise that MUST be true for the argument's conclusion to remain viable. If a necessary assumption is falsified, the core conclusion logically collapses. | ||
| 19 | How do you execute the Negation Technique on a Necessary Assumption choice? | Logically negate the answer choice. If the negated statement shatters or invalidates the argument's conclusion, that choice is the required necessary assumption. If the conclusion survives, eliminate the choice. | ||
| 20 | What is the proper logical negation of 'Always'? | The logical negation of 'Always' is 'Not always' (meaning: 'At least sometimes not'). It is NOT 'Never'. | ||
| 21 | What is the trap of 'Answering the Wrong Question' in CR? | Confusing an answer that explains WHY a decision was made with an answer that justifies whether the decision SHOULD have been made. | ||
| 22 | What is the 2-step methodology for Boldface questions in GMAT CR? | Step 1: Classify each boldface portion as Fact/Evidence, Intermediate Conclusion, Main Conclusion, or Opposing Position. Step 2: Determine whether the two boldface sentences agree with each other or oppose each other. | ||
| 23 | What is the proper logical negation of 'None' in the Negation Test? | The logical negation of 'None are X' is 'At least one is X'. It is NOT 'All are X'. | ||
| 24 | What is the Market Share vs Total Sales Volume trap? | Assuming that increasing market share guarantees higher revenue or unit sales. If the entire market contracted by 50%, a company's market share can rise while its absolute sales plummet. | ||
| 25 | What are the 4 primary ways to strengthen a Causal Argument? | 1. Eliminate an alternative cause for the effect. 2. Show that when the cause is present, the effect occurs. 3. Show that when the cause is absent, the effect does not occur. 4. Show that the causal arrow is not reversed (the effect did not cause the cause). | ||
| 26 | What is the Competitive Retaliation assumption trap in business strategy questions? | Assuming that when Firm A lowers prices or introduces promotions, competitors will remain passive rather than matching discounts and igniting a margin-eroding price war. | ||
| 27 | In Boldface questions, what is the role of a 'Concession' (or 'Acknowledged Counter-Premise')? | It concedes a counter-fact or limitation raised by critics while maintaining that the author's overarching conclusion remains sound despite that limitation. | ||
| 28 | What is the key rule for 'Resolve the Paradox' questions? | Accept BOTH surprising, contradictory facts as 100% true. The correct answer introduces a third fact that explains how both situations can logically coexist without denying either premise. | ||
| 29 | What is the proper logical negation of 'All' in the Negation Test? | The logical negation of 'All are X' is 'Not all are X' (meaning: 'At least one is NOT X'). It is NOT 'None are X'. | ||
| 30 | What are the 4 primary ways to weaken a Causal Argument? | 1. Introduce a plausible alternative cause. 2. Show cause occurs WITHOUT the effect. 3. Show effect occurs WITHOUT the cause. 4. Show reverse causation or a confounding common third variable. | ||
| 31 | How do you evaluate Plan/Policy arguments in GMAT CR? | Focus on two vulnerabilities: (1) Feasibility (can the plan actually be implemented as described?); (2) Unintended consequences that offset or destroy the plan's specific objective. | ||
| 32 | Why is an answer choice that attacks a stated premise wrong in Weaken questions? | Premises in CR are taken as factual evidence. A valid weakener attacks the UNSTATED ASSUMPTION (the logical leap from premise to conclusion), not the empirical truth of the premise itself. |